|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Xenoesterogens
and male infertility: myth or reality?
Roya
Rozati, P.P. Reddy1, P. Reddanna2, Rubina Mujtaba Assisted
Conception Services Unit, Mahavir Hospital and Research Centre, Hyderabad
(A.P.) 500 028, India Asian J Androl 2000 Dec; 2: 263-269 Keywords:
AbstractAim: To evaluate the role of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) as a potential environmental hazard in the deterioration of male fertility. Methods: Fifty-three males were studied. After a thorough case history evaluation and relevant clinical and laboratory investigations, PCBs were estimated in the seminal plasma of 21 infertile men with Unexplained Male Factor and 32 fertile controls. Peak retention times of the eluants were compared with those of the commercially available standard PCB Mix, and the results confirmed spectrophotometrically. Seminal PCB concentrations were compared between i) fertile and infertile men and ii) men from different areas and diets. The relationship between PCB concentrations and measures of sperm quality such as the total motile sperm count, was assessed. Results: PCBs were detected in seminal plasma of infertile men but absent from controls. Sperm quantity and quality were significantly lower in infertile men compared to controls. The highest average PCB concentrations were found in fish-eating urban dwellers, and followed in succession by fish-eating rural dwellers, non fish-eating urban dwellers and non fish-eating rural dwellers. The total motile sperm counts were inversely proportional to the PCB concentrations and were significantly lower than those of the respective controls. Conclusion: PCBs may be instrumental in the deterioration of sperm quantity and quality, a contaminated fish diet being the main source of exposure.1 IntroductionSeveral
studies have reported a decline in semen quality over time[1-3].
Circumstantial evidence is accumulating that environmental xenobiotics
may disrupt reproductive processes in human males. These include disorders
of development and function of the male reproductive tract such as testicular
cancer[4], maldescent (cryptorchidism)[5], urethral
abnormalities (hypospadias)[6], and
a striking drop in semen volume and sperm counts[7]. These
abnormalities have occurred during
periods of increased exposure to and body burdens of oestrogenic chemicals[8]. PCBs
are halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons consisting of complex lipophilic
mixtures of 200 or more congeners with oestrogenic and anti-oestrogenic
effects[9]. Several
adverse have been documented in animals on different organs and at different
metabolic levels such as the thyroid hormone metabolism[10],
gonadal steroidogenesis and semen quality[11], enzyme metabolism[12],
and immune system[13]. In man, levels of some PCB congeners
have been inversely correlated to sperm motility in semen samples with
sperm concentrations <20 million/mL[14]. Boys exposed to
PCBs in utero were shown to have significantly smaller penis[15].
PCBs
have been used extensively as insulators in electrical equipment such
as transformers, ballasts in fluorescent lighting, circuit breakers and
switchgear, as plasticisers in PVC products, in carbonless copy paper,
as de-inking solvents for recycling of newspaper and as waterproofing
agents. They are resistant to degradation, hence widespread and persistent
in the environment. Different routes of exposure include dermal exposure,
ingestion of contaminated water and food, and inhalation of ambient air
contaminated with PCBs. They tend to accumulate in marine and terrestrial
food chains and due to the low biodegradation and excretion in humans,
these substances accumulate in the body fat. Humans are the potential
endpoint reservoirs for PCB contamination in the aquatic ecosystem. The
current major sources of concern are their entry into the environment
from unauthorized disposal practices, landfill leachate, leaks in transformers
and hydraulic and heat transfer systems, and from transformer fires and
transportation spills. Rigorous placebo controlled trials have revealed
many of the supposed treatments for male infertility to be ineffective[16].
Intracytoplasmic sperm
injection (ICSI), the most significant advance in the treatment of men
who will not respond to specific treatment, may carry a substantial recurrence
risk for infertility in the offspring of treated couples[17] as
it allows fertilization with defective sperm
without knowing the cause of the infertility. Identifying and eliminating toxic
factors in the environment that result in this condition is an urgent
need of the day. 2 Materials and methods2.1
Subjects Five
hundred and fifty-seven infertile couples were screened at The Assisted
Conception Services Unit, Mahavir Hospital and Research Centre, a referral
centre that receives cases from all over Andhra Pradesh. A complete case
history evaluation including the nature and duration of infertility, residential
area, habits and addictions, history of illness/disease, occupation, life
style, and diet was made. Laboratory investigations included a routine
semen analysis after a proscribed three-day abstinence[18].
Seminal volume, sperm count, the number and quality of sperm motility,
sperm morphology, sperm hypo-osmotic swelling (HOS)
test, sperm nuclear chromatin stability, and sperm DNA normality were
recorded. The HOS was assessed in a sodium citrate fructose medium[19].
Sperm nuclear chromatin decondensation was analysed following treatment
of spermatozoa with 1% SDS+6 mmol/L EDTA, stained according to the Shorr
method and classified according to the scheme of Rodriguez et al[20]. Individuals
with sperm counts <20 million/mL,
grade A motility 25%, and/or
30% normal forms, and/or hypo-osmotic swelling test scores 50% were
considered to have a male factor problem. In 300 individuals with a male
factor problem, an obvious cause for the infertility could be found in
44.52% of the men, while no cause could
be identified in 9.34%. These men were diagnozed Unexplained Male Factor
infertility. PCBs were estimated in the seminal plasma of 21 infertile
men with unexplained male factor and 32 controls. Male partners of women
with a previous conception were selected as controls. Criteria for the
inclusion of infertile men included i) no history of associated clinical
pathology eg, varicocoele, retractile testis, cryptorchidism, hormonal
disorders, ii) no history of febrile illness in the six months prior to
analysis, iii) no history of smoking or tobacco consumption,
iv) no evidence of semen infection. On the basis of the possible source
of PCBs, men were
further subcategorized into i) fish-eating urban dwellers, ii) fish-eating rural
dwellers, iii) non fish-eating urban dwellers with an exclusively vegetarian
diet, and iv) non fish-eating rural dwellers with an exclusively vegetarian
diet. The total motile sperm count was taken as a measure of semen quality.
It was calculated as the product of grade 2+3 motility and the sperm concentration.
For the sake of comparison of semen quality between these sub-categories
of men, two control groups of fertile men were considered: i) Control
1: urban men with a
mixed diet and no reported consumption of fish, and ii) Control 2: rural
men with a mixed diet and no reported consumption of fish. Urban was
used to denote areas within the control of the Muncipal Health Corporation
whereas 'Rural' was used to denote areas not within Muncipal control. 2.2
Assays The extraction of xenoestrogens was carried out by the method described by Burse et al[21]. The extraction procedure was divided into five phases. 2.2.1
Phase 1: Isolation of seminal plasma Semen
was collected as a part of the treatment protocol and after analysis of
the semen parameters, seminal plasma was isolated by centrifugation at
2000g for 20 min. 2.2.2
Phase 2: Removal of sex steroids by Charcoal-Dextran treatment. Charcoal
(Norit A, acid washed, Sigma) was washed with cold sterile water immediately
before use. A 5% charcoal and 0.5% dextran T-70 (D-4876, Sigma) suspension
was prepared. Charcoal-Dextran (CD) suspension aliquots of a volume similar
to that of seminal plasma aliquots to be processed were centrifuged at
100g for 10 min. Supernatants were aspirated and seminal plasma aliquots
mixed with charcoal pellets. The charcoal seminal plasma mixture was maintained
by rolling at 4 cycles/min at 37 for 1 hour. The suspension was centrifuged
at 2000g for 20 min. The supernatant was then filtered through a Nalgene
filter with a pore size of 0.45 m. 2.2.3
Phase 3: Extraction of xenoestrogens Extraction
of xenoestrogens was performed by the method described by Burse et
al[21] with modifications. CD-treated seminal plasma was
divided into two parts. One part was used as a blank and a known quantity
of standard PCB (Polychlorinated biphenyl mix, Supelco) was added to the
other part to establish a comparison with the blank and so as to monitor
the recovery of the added chemical. The two
aliquots were allowed to equilibrate at room temperature. The extracts
from the blank preparation
are devoid of absorbance at 280 nm, and therefore do not interfere with
the quantification of synthetic xenoestrogens. CD-treated seminal plasma
lacks estrogenic activity. Sample
extraction: 1 mL of methanol was added to each of 2 mL aliquots of seminal
plasma, mixed by vortexing, and then 3 mL of hexane:ethyl ether (1:1 by
vol) (HPLC grade, Spectrochem) was added to extract the mixture. The mixture
was agitated on a
rotary mixer for 15 min, and then centrifuged at 2000g for 5 min. The
organic phase was collected and the aqueous phase extracted twice more.
The organic phases
were pooled and subsequently concentrated to 1
mL by evaporation under nitrogen steam. 2.2.4
Phase 4: Acid clean-up of the organic phase prior to high performance
liquid chromatography (HPLC) Concentrated sulphuric acid 0.5 mL was added to the concentrated 1 mL of sample of organic phase. The organic phase was seperated, and the aqueous phase extracted twice more with 1 mL hexane. The organic phases were pooled and dried completely under nitrogen. The sample was resuspended in hexane and then injected into HPLC. 2.2.5
Phase 5: HPLC analysis Seperation
was performed by the method of Medina and Sherman[22] modified
by Sonnenschein et al[23] in a Shimadzu LC6A Liquid
Chromatograph Solvent Delivery System; Shimadzu SCL-6A System Controller;
Shimadzu SPD-6AV UV-vis Spectrophotometric detector equipped with a C-R6A
Chromatopac. Aliquots
of 500 L were injected into a 4220 Partisil 5 silica column (Whatman)
equilibrated with 100% n-hexane (Phase A), and n-hexane:
methanol: isopropanol (40:45:15 by vol) (Phase B) at a flow rate of 1.5
mL/min and a pressure of 510-6 Pa. All the organic solvents
were of HPLC grade, filtered with a 0.22 m filter and degassed prior
to use. The gradient was developed as follows: 100% n-hexane was
allowed to pass through the column for 2 min, following which the concentration
of solvent B was increased to 10% in 10 min, 20% in the next 15 min, 50%
in the next 5 min, and 100% in the next 5 min. Solvent B 100%
was maintained in the column for 5 min before the concentration
of solvent B was reduced to zero. The elution profile was monitored on
a Shimadzu SPD-6AV UV-Vis Spectrophotometric detector at 280 nm with an
absorbance range of 0.001 to 2.56. The chromatogram was
recorded on a C-R6A Chromatopac (Shimadzu). Prior
to standardisation with the commercially available standards and the sample
runs, a hexane blank was injected. For each patient, 2 samples were run:
a seminal plasma blank and a seminal plasma to sample
which a known amount of PCB was added. The
peak HPLC fractions were collected in aliquots and the spectrum of each
fraction confirmed spectrophotometrically with a UV 1601 UV Visible Spectrophotometer
using a working wavelength of 210-320 nm. Fractions with peak absorbances
at the suggested wavelength were recorded to differentiate compound peaks
from solvent peaks. The peak retention times of the blank sample were
compared with those of the
PCB-added sample and standard PCB retention times.
Following spectrophotometric estimation, the fractions with peak
absorbances at 280 nm were pooled, evaporated under liquid nitrogen, resuspended
in hexane and reinjected into the HPLC unit
to purify the compound and verify the peak retention times of the eluted
compounds. Estrogenic
pesticides, PCBs, hydroxylated PCBs, phenolic antioxidants and plasticizers
elute from the HPLC column during the first 10 min, whereas ovarian estrogens,
phytoestrogens, DES, and mycoestrogens are retained for more than 12 min.
The concentration of the eluted compound was calculated from the area
percentage under each peak. Individual PCB fractions were pooled and expressed
as total PCBs in g/mL. Individual PCB congener levels are however presented
as a separate publication. The PCB concentrations and semen parameters
namely sperm count, sperm
motility, sperm morphology, sperm osmoregulatory capacity and measures
of sperm function
such as sperm nuclear chromatin stability and DNA normality were compared
between infertile men and controls. PCB levels and total motile counts
were compared among infertile men from different areas and with different
diets. The detection limits of PCBs ranged from 0.00323 to 14.97 g/mL
with a percentage
recovery of 80.75%. 2.3
Ethics Evaluation
of semen analysis parameters was executed as a part of the treatment protocol,
thus obviating the need for an informed consent. 2.4
Statistical analysis 3
Results It
was observed that
the ejaculate volume, sperm concentration, grade 3, grade 2+3 motility,
the hypo-osmotic swelling test, and sperm nuclear chromatin stability
were significantly lower in the infertile men compared to controls. Head
defects and percentage of single,
stranded DNA were significantly higher in the infertile men. PCBs
were detected in the seminal plasma of infertile patients but absent in
fertile controls (Table 1). Table
1. Semen values and xenoestrogen concentrations (meanSD) in infertile
men and controls.
Irrespective of the diet, when a comparison was drawn between urban and rural infertile men, it was found that urban dwellers had higher seminal PCB concentrations and significantly lower total motile sperm counts than rural dwellers. Likewise, a comparison between fish-eaters and non fish-eaters, irrespective of the dwelling revealed higher PCB concentrations and significantly lower total motile sperm counts in fisheaters than in non fisheaters (Tables 2,3). Table
2. PCB concentration and semen quality (mean values).
Control
1: Fertile men from urban areas with a mixed diet (excluding fish). Table
3. Kolmogobov smirnov test for the differences in total motile sperm counts
between infertile men and controls.
bP<0.05 4
Discussion This
study carried out on infertile men is the first report from the Indian
sub-continent demonstrating the presence of PCBs in semen samples. The
presence of PCBs in the seminal plasma of occupationally unexposed infertile
men, their absence from fertile controls, and the significantly poor semen
parameters in this group is a clue to the possible role of PCBs in the
deterioration of sperm quantity and quality. These chemicals are ubiquitous
in the environment. The
significantly lower ejaculate volume in infertile men with PCBs provides
evidence for the effect of these chemicals on accessory gland function.
Organs that appear to
be at particular risk for estrogenic effects are those with receptors
for gonadal hormones in the male- the prostate, seminal vesicles, epididymides
and testes[24]. Xenoestrogens may modulate the hormonal milieu
within the prostate and seminal
vesicles by possibly interfering with androgen binding to the androgen
receptors. They may interfere with hormone mediated events in the testis
and epididymis by either binding to sex-hormone binding globulin (SHBG)
and androgen binding protein (ABP), or blocking the cell-surface receptors[25]
for these proteins, thus inhibiting normal signal transduction. The
underlying cause of most of the reproductive effects of PCBs may be alterations
in steroid hormone metabolism. PCBs may interfere with hormone-mediated
events in the testis and epididymis by down-regulating testicular androgenesis
through an acute inhibition of 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase, 17alpha-hydroxylase/lyase,
and 17beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase activities[26]. Studies
have reported an over 50% inhibition of the activity of mitochondrial
CYP11A, the rate-limiting enzyme for steroidogenesis in testes of the
PCB-contaminated bulls[27]. The higher PCB concentrations in fish-eaters than non fish-eaters observed in our study are comparable to studies reporting elevated concentrations of organochlorine compounds in the tissues of people consuming large amounts of contaminated seafood when compared to the general population[29]. The dietary intake of PCBs is expected to account for 89-99% of human exposure to these compounds[30]. PCB concentrations dominate the levels of the six contaminants that are most often detected in fish which concentrate the toxicants to millions of times the background levels. PCBs that are associated with the fats of fish or animal flesh cannot be removed by washing and are only partially removed by cooking procedures[31]. Due to the low biodegradation and excretion in humans, these substances accumulate in the body fat, and their concentrations reflect external exposure[32]. Environmental
exposure to improperly disposed industrial effluents from major industries
such as cement and cement products, synthetic drugs and pharmaceuticals,
petrochemicals, plastic industries, heavy electricals, fertilisers, tobacco
and coal, may account for observations of higher PCB concentrations and
the concomitantly lower total motile sperm counts in urban dwellers than
in rural dwellers in our study. The
presence of PCBs in rural dwellers with a vegetarian diet can be traced
to the bio-magnification
of the chemical through the consumption of edible plants grown on contaminated
soil. In developing nations, as much as 95% of untreated sewage is dumped
directly into rivers, lakes, and coastal waters which may be used for
irrigation, drinking and bathing. Sewage effluents are estrogenic[33].
Sewage treatment appears to remove particulate PCBs from water but not
PCBs in solution which may ultimately be stored in the lipopolysaccharides
of the plant cells and the toxicity bio-magnified within the higher portion
of the food chain in either land animals or humans. Acknowledgements References [1]
Auger J, Kuntsmann JM, Czyglik F, Jouannet P. Decline in semen quality
among fertile men in Paris during the past 20 years. N Engl J Med 1995;
332: 281-5. Correspondence
to: Dr.
Roya Rozati, Assisted Conception Services Unit, Mahavir Hospital and Research
Centre, 10-1-1/A, Bhagwan Mahavir Marg, A.C.
Guards, Hyderabad (A.P.) 500 028, INDIA.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |