|
||
Effects of acut and chronic doses of methoxy acetic acid on hamster sperm fertilising abilityL.D.C.
Peiris1, H.D.M. Moore2 1Dept.
of Zoology, University of Colombo, Colombo 03, Sri Lanka Asian J Androl 2001 Sep; 3: 185-191 Keywords:
AbstractAim: 1
Introduction
Fertilisation
in vivo requires adequate numbers of spermatozoa to
be ejaculated with normal morphology and motility[1]. Since
spermatogenesis involves a complex process of cellular development, the
impairment to any of the stages may lead to a reduction in fertility.
Spermatogenesis has been shown to be susceptible to the damaging effect of
a variety of chemical agents[2]. The
relationship between the chemical damage to the testis and the male fertility
is poorly understood in mammals. Specific damage to germ cells within
the testis may take several weeks to become apparent and may not affect
the fertilising capacity of all the sperm so that residual fertility remains.
Furthermore, at low exposure of toxicant, the effects on sperm development
may be subtle and involve changes to sperm function that are not apparent
by standard testing such as animal mating trials. In this respect, rodent
animal models have been useful to assess the effects of testicular toxicants[3,4]. Methoxy
acetic acid (MAA) is widely used as a solvent in the manufacture of protective
coatings such as lacquers, enamels, phenolic varnishes and alkyl resins.
MAA is also used as an intermediate chemical for the production of ethylene
glycolmonomethyl ether (EGME), a common plasticiser used by paint, printing, textile
and leather industries[5,6]. Studies
have shown that administration of single oral doses of MAA to rats caused
selective and stagedependent destruction of late pachytene and diplotene
spermatocytes[6-9]. Later the degeneration extended to early
and mid-stages of spermatocytes and to round spermatids[9].
At lower dose levels, the effects were less pronounced or confined to
fewer stages of spermatogenesis. Ratnasooriya and Sharpe[10]
treated rats with a single dose of 650 mg/kg of MAA and found similar
results to earlier toxicological studies. In addition, they observed a
reduction in sperm motility at 4-7 weeks post-treatment but with no evidence
of infertility. Chronic doses of MAA resulted in the reduction in testicular
weights[11] in addition to the above mentioned effects. 2 Materials and methods2.1 Hamster colony Adult
(6 weeks old) Syrian (Golden) hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus)
were purchased from Harlan (UK). Animals were maintained on 13
h light and 11 h dark cycle in a room that was lit by artificial light
from 06:00 to 19:00. The animal room was kept at (202)
and a relative humidity of 45 %-55 %. Animals were fed on a pellet diet
with free access to water and animals
were allowed to acclimatise for at least 2 weeks before use. 2.2 Chemicals MAA, >98 % pure, was purchased from Aldrich(UK), while all other chemicals were purchased from Sigma (UK) unless stated otherwise. Solutions of MAA were prepared with distilled water just prior to use.2.3 Treatment of hamsters Experiment
1 (acute dose): 36 male hamsters were given a single dose of MAA at either
650, 160 or 80 mg/kg. The total dosing solution was 1 mL. Control animals
(n=12) received the same amount of distilled water. 2.4 In vitro fertilisation The method described by Bavister[13] was used. The medium used for in vitro fertilisation was a modified Krebs-Ringers solution (BWW) developed by Biggers et al[14]. This medium was supplemented with 4 mg/mL crystalline bovine serum albumin. The final solution was filter sterilised (0.2 m, Gelman Sciences, UK) and 100 l aliquots of medium were placed in the tissue culture Petri dishes (3510 mm, Corning Glass Wear, USA) and immediately covered with warm liquid paraffin (Boots Co., Nottingham, UK). Petri dishes with medium were equilibrated overnight in an atmosphere of 5 % carbon dioxide in air at 37 in a humidified incubator. The final pH of the medium was 7.4. The osmotic pressure was between 280-300 mOsm as determined by freezing point depression osmometer (Camlab, UK).2.5 Collection of cauda epididymal sperm The hamsters were killed by sodium pentobarbitone (J.M. Loveridge, Southampton, UK) given intraperitoneally. For the IVF procedure, the left distal cauda epididymidis was dissected out and placed in 2 mL of equilibrated BWW medium in a tissue culture dish. The epididymal tubules were teased apart to allow sperm to swim out into the medium.2.6 Staining of hamster spermatozoa with Hoechst 33342 Sperm released from the distal cauda epididymidis were incubated in BWW medium with 2 g/mL Hoechst 33342 (bisbenzimide) for 30 min and centrifuged (Beckman, UK) for 4 min at 600 g. The sperm pellet was resuspended in BWW medium and washed again by centrifugation. To induce capacitation, sperm (~107/mL) were incubated in the medium in a humidified atmosphere of 5 % carbon dioxide in air at 37 for 3 h.2.7 Collection of oocytes Immature,
female Syrian hamsters were superovulated with 40 IU of PMSG (Pregnant
Mare's Serum Gonadotropin). The PMSG was administered at 11.00 h intraperitoneally
(i.p.). Two days later, 40 IU of hCG (Human Chrionic Gonadotropin) was
given i.p. to each female at 17:00. Animals were killed at 11:00 the next
d. Ovaries and oviducts were dissected out in BWW medium and oviducts were
ruptured with a fine needle to release the cumulus mass. The
cumulus was dissolved by 0.1 % bovine serum testicular hyaluronidase in
the medium for 10 min. Cumulus-free eggs were washed twice by
pipette in the BWW medium and were kept at 37
under oil until insemination. 2.8 Insemination of oocytes After 3 h of incubation, the stock sperm suspension was adjusted so that the final concentration of sperm used for inseminating oocytes was 5105/mL-1106/mL. The oocytes were transferred to the sperm suspension and the culture dishes were returned to the humidified incubator at 37 in 5 % CO2 in air.2.9 Evaluation of fertilisation Four hours after insemination, eggs were pipetted out, washed with BWW medium thoroughly to remove the sperm attached to the zona surface and mounted between a slide and a coverslip with Vaseline spots for support. The eggs were moderately compressed under the coverslip and examined with a phase-contrast microscope (BH2, Olympus, Japan) and ultraviolet light with a wavelength of 395-440 nm filter for evidence of a decondensing sperm head or the presence of pronuclei. Fertilisation was normally confirmed by the presence of the sperm tail in the egg vitellus under phase-contrast.2.10 Histological studies The
right testis was dissected out, blotted dry to remove any blood,
cut into small
slices and fixed in Bouin's fluid for 24 h. The tissues were washed free
of Bouin's fluid and stored in 70 % alcohol until embedding. The
tissues were dehydrated in alcohol series and embedded in melted wax.
Tissue sections of 4 m thickness were made and placed on glass slides. 2.11 Statistical analysis Statistical analysis was performed with one way analysis of variance (ANOVA) using Minitab software for the main effect of toxicants. Where a significant treatment effect was found, differences among individual group means were tested by the least significant test. The null hypothesis for each testing was that there was no significant difference between the fertilisation rates or sperm counts ofthe control and treated animals. Additionally, the relationship between dose and fertilisation rates was examined by linear regression analysis. Values were considered statistically significant at P<0.05. The data are expressed as meanSD.3
Results 3.1 Effect of fluorescent staining of hamster sperm on IVF Staining
of hamster sperm with Hoechst 33342 did not effect their fertilising ability
since it was able to obtain highly consistent (>90 %) fertilisation
rates for the controls. With stained sperm, all stages of sperm head decondensation (Figure 1A-B) and the presence of pronuclei (Figure 1C) in fertilised oocytes were easily and quickly identified by distinct blue fluorescence. Decondensed sperm heads were of either elliptical (Figure 1A) or round (Figure 1B) shape of different sizes. Care was taken when scoring oocytes to confirm the presence of the sperm tail in the egg vitellus. Figure 1. Micrographs of fluorescence of DNA stained at different stages of fertilisation. Penetrated spermatozoon head within the egg appeared initially elliptical (A) & later became large and diffuse (B). Both are indicated by arrows (C). fertilised oocyte showing male & female pronuclei. Polar body is also fluorescent. Magnification 200.3.2 General toxicity of MAA At acute and chronic dose levels no overt signs of general toxicity were observed in the treated animals and the body weights were comparable to those of the control hamsters.3.3 Effects of MAA on fertilisation in vitro Similar patterns of results were obtained with both zona-intact and zona-free eggs.3.3.1 Effects of acute doses of MAA The
fertilisation rates in the control group were consistently greater than
90 % throughout the experiment (Figure 2). 3.3.2 Effects of chronic doses of MAA Males
treated with 8 mg/kg MAA had significantly reduced sperm fertility from
week 1 to week 4 after exposure. Males given 32 mg/kg MAA showed a reduction
in sperm fertility throughout the experimental period except at week 5. Figure 2. Fertilisation rates of male hamsters treated with three acute doses (A, zona intact eggs & B, zona free eggs) and three chronic doses (C, zona intact eggs & D, zona free eggs) of MAA. Spermatogenic stages are given with the graphs. Ed s'zoa=epididymal spermatozoa, S'tids=spermatids; P=pachytene spermatocytes, Z=zygotene spermatocytes, L=leptotene spermatocytes, PL=preleptotene spermatocytes and S'gonia=spermatogonia. *P<0.05 & **P<0.01, compared with controls. 3.4 Histology Testes sections from control males displayed consistently good histological preservation indicating that the fixation method and tissue processing was optimal. A series of representative micrographs are shown in Figure 3 (A-B) with increasing order of magnification. The germinal epithelium is well preserved with all the cell types present. There are no vacuoles in the epithelium and the lamina of the tubules do not contain sloughed immature cell types.3.4.1 Acute exposure to MAA At the lowest acute dose, testicular damage was only evident at the first week of treatment and was restricted to individual tubule sections. Sloughed clusters of spermatocytes were observed in certain sections (Figure 3C). At later stages after treatment there was no obvious differences between the control and treated animals. At the higher dose levels, the effects of toxicant became more apparent at the first two weeks after treatment. Tubule sections contained many sloughed cells, the majority of which were pachytene spermatocytes, although some other cell types (i.e., spermatids) were also present. This effect was most pronounced at the first week after treatment. Representative micrographs of damage are shown in Figures 3D and 3E. By 3 and 4 weeks after treatment, the lamina of tubule sections were free of debris but the germinal epithelium exhibited a diminished population of elongatated spermatids (Figure 3F).3.4.2 Chronic exposure to MAA The lowest chronic dose had little effect on testis histology at any time after treatment. At the first two weeks sporadic tubule sections contained sloughed cells of mixed cell types but many tubule sections looked normal. At the high dose levels there were noticeable effects on the testis. Two weeks after treatment many tubules contained sloughed cells similar to the high acute dose after week 1 (Figure 3G). However by week 4 of treatment a proportion of tubules was depleted of later stages cells, which were not recovered at the end of the observation period (Figure 3H).Figure
3. Micrographs of testicular sections. 4
Discussion It
is well documented that MAA damages the germinal epithelium in the rat.
A number of toxicity trials has been
carried out using mating protocols and only a few studies[4,12,15]
used in vitro fertilisation procedures. The
number of sperm inseminated is a crucial factor to obtain successful fertilisation
rates. Talbot et al[16] failed to achieve high fertilisation
rates at sperm number higher or below 1106/0.5 mL. They were
able to obtain the highest fertilisation
rates when they inseminated a sperm concentration of 1106/0.5
mL. A drop in the percentage of eggs penetrated at sperm concentration
above 1106/0.5 mL were observed and this may be due to exhaustion
of certain metabolites, accumulation of toxic products, or inhibition
of capacitation. A
fall in fertilisation rates with low sperm concentration could be due
to diminishing probability of egg and capacitated sperm collision. Holloway
et al[12] found that the best concentration of sperm
to obtain optimal fertilisation rates was
between 3105-1106/mL per 20-30 eggs. Hence,
in the present study, the sperm concentration for insemination was always
kept between 5105 and 1106 /mL. A consistently
high percentage of oocyte fertilised in the controls (90 %-100 %) indicated
that this sperm concentration gave optimal fertilisation rates. The results
were similar to those reported by Stein and Schnieden (90 %-100 %)[17]
and Yanagimachi (100
%)[18]. The
spermatogenic cycle of the hamster is about 35 d and epididymal sperm
transit varies from 7 to 10 d[20]. Therefore in the case of
acute treatment, there is a lag period from the time of initial exposure
to a testicular toxicant to the time when the cauda epididymidis sperm
may be affected. For example,
if at week 1, sperm fertilising capacity is already affected, the toxicant may
have penetrated the cauda epididymidis to directly compromise sperm. If
sperm in the cauda epididymidis are affected only after 3 and 4 weeks,
it would indicate that the round spermatids and pachytene spermatocytes
were compromised at the time of the treatment. As
the acute dose of MAA was increased, the number of stages of germ cells
affected and the severity of toxicity were also increased. At the lowest
dose of 80 mg/kg, the
fertilising capacity of sperm was reduced only slightly at week 3. At
the 160 mg/kg dose, the decline in sperm fertilising capacity was in keeping
with pachytene spermatocytes and possibly also spermatogonia damage, while
at the 650 mg/kg,
the results were consistent with round spermatids and epididymal spermatozoa
damage as well. Histological studies also revealed that spermtocytes are
the most sensitive stage. Previous
in vivo and in vitro studies in the rat identified meiotic pachytene
spermatocytes as an early target for MAA toxicity[21]. Later
studies with the related compound EGME also indicated that spermatids
were affected[12]. In keeping with the studies in other rodents,
the present histological data also revealed that the spermatocytes are
the most sensitive cell type affected by MAA. In addition, early spermatids
were also sensitive to the toxicant. Stages 8-12 being particularly prone
to damage after exposure. Pachytene spermatocytes make up a greater complement
of the germinal epithelium in these stages. A
significant observation made in the present study was the inhibition of
fertility of epididymal sperm with 650 mg/kg of MAA after week 1. This
has not been recorded in previous studies and may be due to species differences.
The result would indicate that epididymal sperm or very late spermatids
can be directly affected by MAA. In
serial mating trials in rats with MAA using comparable doses to the present study,
Ratnasooriya and Sharpe[10] did not observe any significant
reduction in fertility, although they observed histological depletion
in selective germ cells. This may indicate species difference or perhaps
the sensitivity of the IVF model used in this study[4,12,15]. Compared
with the males treated with an acute dose of MAA, those given chronic doses had
lower sperm fertilising capacity throughout the observation period, thus
indicating that chronic doses may be more toxic than acute doses. Compared
with the controls,
there was a significant decline in sperm fertility of males exposed to
8 mg/kg or 32 mg/kg
of MAA, although this was not as great as in case of 64 mg/kg. At the
lowest dose, the sperm fertilising ability was fully recovered by week
5, whereas for males treated with 32 mg/kg or 64 mg/kg, recovery was incomplete
even at week 6. The results show that 64 mg/kg of MAA must have caused
extensive damage even to the spermatid population which is evident by
very low fertilisation rates. Histological
studies also revealed that chronic doses of MAA caused similar effects
on the testis as the acute dose, but were effective at a lower level and
caused a more persistent damage to the seminiferous tubules. Spermatocytes
were the first to be affected, but with the progress of time more cell
types were damaged. Beyond week 4, the fertilisation rates began to increase
and this may be due to a partial recovery of the pachytene and preleptotene
spermatocyte populations. Immediately
after the end of the treatment period, males given 64 mg/kg of MAA had
no sperm in the cauda epididymidis. This observation indicates that spermatogonia
are affected when a chronic dose is given over a long time. Histological
studies carried out by Foster et al[8] revealed that
repeated treatment of rats for 11 d with EGME resulted in continuous spermatocyte
degeneration and depletion of
spermatid population, leaving only the Sertoli cells. The present study
also showed extensive
damage to the germ cells, yet the effects are more marked in the spermatid
population. Since no studies have been conducted previously on hamsters
exposed to such a prolonged dosing, it is difficult to compare the present
results with previously recorded results. Acknowledgements The authors thank the Commonwealth Scholarship Commission, UK for the financial support and Mr. Nick Jenkins for gavaging the hamsters.References [1]
Adamopoulos DA, Pappa A, Nicopoulou S, Andreou S, Karamertzans M, Michopoulos J,
et al. Seminal volume and total sperm number: trends in men attending
subfertility clinics in the greater Athens area during the period 1977-1993.
Hum Reprod 1996; 11: 1936-41. Correspondence
to: Dr.
L.D.C. Peiris, Dept. of Zoology, University of Colombo, Colombo 03, Sri
Lanka.
|
||
![]() |